WrestleMania has produced some of the most legendary matches in wrestling history. Fans often remember the marquee bouts—like The Rock vs. Stone Cold Steve Austin or The Undertaker’s iconic streak—but many outstanding matches get overlooked. These underrated WrestleMania matches showcase storytelling, athleticism, and drama that rival the biggest main events, yet they don’t always get the respect they deserve. Whether it’s because of a stacked card, backstage politics, or simply being ahead of their time, these gems are worth revisiting. If you’re a fan looking to rediscover matches that highlight the true art of pro wrestling, this list will guide you to some of the best hidden classics in WrestleMania history. Here are four of the most overlooked matches that deserve a fresh watch and greater appreciation.
1. Randy Orton vs. Seth Rollins — WrestleMania 31
Randy Orton vs. Seth Rollins (image via Getty)Although WrestleMania 31 is often remembered for the epic “heist of the century” when Seth Rollins cashed in his Money in the Bank contract, his singles match with Randy Orton earlier that night was a technical masterpiece. This contest blended brutal in-ring psychology with breathtaking reversals, leading to what many consider one of the greatest RKO moments ever. Rollins’ attempted Curb Stomp turning into a mid-air RKO was a jaw-dropping finish that still gets replayed today. Beyond the finish, both superstars demonstrated impeccable timing and storytelling. Overshadowed by the main event’s surprise twist, this match deserves recognition as one of the sharpest and most well-executed showdowns in WrestleMania history.
2. Chris Jericho vs. William Regal — WrestleMania X-Seven
WrestleMania X-Seven is hailed as one of the greatest shows ever, but its opening bout between Chris Jericho and William Regal for the Intercontinental Championship often gets lost amid an incredible card. Yet, this match is a technical showcase of two of the best grapplers to ever step in the ring. With Regal working as the cunning commissioner and Jericho playing the brash champion, their chemistry was undeniable. The storytelling focused on Regal targeting Jericho’s shoulder while Jericho found creative ways to counter. Despite being overshadowed by TLC II and Austin vs. Rock, this match is a crisp, hard-hitting contest that stands the test of time. Fans of technical wrestling owe it to themselves to revisit this underrated gem.
3. CM Punk vs. Chris Jericho — WrestleMania 28
CM Punk vs. Chris Jericho (image via Getty)When discussing classic WrestleMania matches, CM Punk vs. Chris Jericho for the WWE Championship at WrestleMania 28 rarely comes up, even though it delivered one of the night’s most compelling narratives. Fueled by a personal storyline where Jericho targeted Punk’s family and sobriety, the stakes felt real and intense. What followed was a match filled with counter-wrestling, near-falls, and dramatic moments that kept fans guessing. Punk and Jericho’s chemistry was off the charts, creating a smooth and intelligent contest that showcased their ability to tell a story in the ring. While The Rock vs. John Cena headlined that night, this match was arguably the strongest from a pure wrestling standpoint and deserves far more attention.
4. Rey Mysterio vs. Cody Rhodes — WrestleMania 27
WrestleMania 27 is not often cited among the best editions of the event, but one match that truly shined was Rey Mysterio vs. Cody Rhodes. At the time, Rhodes was developing his “Disfigured” persona, wearing a protective mask and playing a bitter, psychologically damaged character. The story heading into the match was personal, with Rhodes blaming Mysterio for his facial injuries. Their encounter was fast-paced and emotional and featured creative offense on both sides. Mysterio brought his high-flying arsenal, while Rhodes targeted Rey’s knee and made great use of his mask for heel tactics. It was a rare chance for Rhodes to showcase his potential long before he would become a major headliner. This match is often overlooked, but it’s a standout from a WrestleMania card that lacked many memorable moments.
WrestleMania is filled with timeless classics, but these overlooked matches deserve to be part of any true fan’s watchlist. Each of these contests demonstrates that even without the top billing, incredible performances can steal the show when given the chance. Whether you’re revisiting or watching them for the first time, these hidden classics are worth every minute.