WWE has delivered countless Pay-Per-Views (PPVs) over the last decade, but not every show gets the recognition it deserves. Some events slip under the radar, overshadowed by bigger names like WrestleMania or Royal Rumble, yet they feature top-tier matches, memorable moments, and brilliant storytelling. For fans looking to revisit WWE’s recent history or discover something they might have missed, these PPVs offer a fresh experience filled with excitement and drama. Whether you’re a long-time fan or a newcomer, checking out these lesser-known shows can remind you of just how entertaining WWE can be when firing on all cylinders. Here are four of the most underrated WWE PPVs from the last ten years that are absolutely worth watching.
\1. WWE Payback 2016 — A Storytelling Masterclass
The Shield vs. Evolution (Image via Getty)Payback 2016 is often overlooked, but it delivered one of the best cards of that year. Headlined by Roman Reigns vs. AJ Styles for the WWE World Heavyweight Championship, this PPV was packed with high-stakes matches and emotional storytelling. The chemistry between Reigns and Styles was electric, with both men telling a physical, believable story that blurred the line between heel and babyface.
Additionally, Kevin Owens vs. Sami Zayn added a personal and hard-hitting match to the mix, showcasing their real-life rivalry in spectacular fashion. Even the tag team match between The Vaudevillains and The New Day helped set the tone for the division moving forward. Payback 2016 proved that even “B-level” shows could rival the big four when booked right.
2. WWE TLC 2016 — Tables, Ladders, and Chaos
TLC 2016 is often forgotten, but it showcased one of the best main events of the year: AJ Styles vs. Dean Ambrose for the WWE Championship in a TLC match. This contest was filled with brutal spots, creative ladder usage, and intense action that kept fans guessing until the end.
Another highlight was The Miz defending the Intercontinental Championship against Dolph Ziggler in a ladder match. Their chemistry and storytelling elevated the title, reminding fans how important mid-card belts can be when given the spotlight.
Plus, Bray Wyatt and Randy Orton, as part of The Wyatt Family, captured the SmackDown Tag Team Titles, adding an intriguing chapter to their evolving partnership. TLC 2016 delivered far more excitement than many remember.
3. WWE Fastlane 2019 — Unexpected Surprises and Match Quality
WWE Fastlane 2019 (Image via Getty)Fastlane 2019 entered as a transitional show on the road to WrestleMania 35, but it ended up exceeding expectations. The Shield’s reunion match, featuring Roman Reigns, Seth Rollins, and Dean Ambrose teaming up one last time, provided a feel-good moment for fans. Their bout against Baron Corbin, Drew McIntyre, and Bobby Lashley was fast-paced and action-packed.
The triple threat for the WWE Championship — Daniel Bryan vs. Kevin Owens vs. Mustafa Ali — turned into an underrated gem, filled with near-falls and high drama. Ali, a late addition to the match, made a huge impression.
Even the Women’s Tag Team Title match with Bayley and Sasha Banks defending against Nia Jax and Tamina added value, pushing the division forward. Fastlane 2019 proved to be a pleasant surprise with high entertainment value.
4. WWE Extreme Rules 2018 — More Than Just Gimmicks
Despite being labeled as a gimmick-heavy show, Extreme Rules 2018 had strong in-ring action and meaningful stories. The standout match was AJ Styles vs. Rusev for the WWE Championship. Rusev, in the midst of his “Rusev Day” popularity, pushed Styles to the limit, creating a match that balanced technical skill with emotional investment.
Seth Rollins vs. Dolph Ziggler for the Intercontinental Championship in a 30-minute Iron Man match was another highlight. Their chemistry was undeniable, and the pacing of the match kept the crowd engaged until the final second.
Additionally, the Raw Tag Team Title match featuring the B-Team defeating Matt Hardy and Bray Wyatt added a fun and unexpected title change, bringing energy to the card. Extreme Rules 2018 had a lot more to offer than many gave it credit for.
These overlooked WWE PPVs remind fans that sometimes the most enjoyable shows are the ones flying under the radar. They feature incredible talent, memorable moments, and matches that stand the test of time. If you’re searching for something different from the usual highlights, these events are well worth watching — proof that WWE magic isn’t confined to only the biggest shows of the year.