WWE Matches That Ended in a Double Pinfall

Professional wrestling has always been about larger-than-life moments, but few moments are as intense and controversial as a double pinfall. These rare outcomes leave fans on the edge of their seats, questioning who really won. Whether intentional or accidental, double pinfalls can add an unexpected twist to rivalries and championships, making them unforgettable. WWE has seen several matches end in this dramatic fashion, often sparking rematches or continuing heated storylines. These moments not only display the fierce competition between superstars but also highlight how closely matched some rivals truly are. Let’s revisit some of the most famous WWE matches that ended with both competitors’ shoulders on the mat — a finish that neither competitor wants but every fan remembers.

1. Bret Hart vs. Lex Luger — 1994 Royal Rumble

One of the most famous double finishes in WWE history occurred during the 1994 Royal Rumble Match, when both Bret “The Hitman” Hart and Lex Luger were the last two men standing — or rather, falling. As they struggled near the ropes, both superstars tumbled over the top rope at the same time, hitting the floor simultaneously. This rare moment created confusion among referees, who debated who had touched down first. Unable to decide, officials ruled both men as co-winners, setting up a path to WrestleMania X where both earned WWE Championship matches. This iconic double finish raised the stakes for months to come and remains one of the most memorable Royal Rumble endings.

2. Undertaker vs. Batista — Last Man Standing Match (Backlash 2007)

At Backlash 2007, The Undertaker defended the World Heavyweight Championship against Batista in a brutal Last Man Standing match. The two powerhouses unleashed everything in their arsenals, including steel steps, chairs, and crushing slams. As the battle wore on, both men were exhausted yet unrelenting. The finish saw Batista spear The Undertaker off the stage, causing an explosion that left both competitors unable to answer the referee’s 10-count. Since neither man could stand before the count ended, the match was ruled a draw, allowing The Undertaker to retain his title. This double finish added more fuel to their fierce rivalry and proved just how evenly matched they were at the time.

3. AJ Styles vs. James Ellsworth — SmackDown (2016)

While James Ellsworth may not be a name typically associated with main event status, his underdog storyline in 2016 led to a memorable bout with then-WWE Champion AJ Styles. During their title match on SmackDown Live, interference from Dean Ambrose set up a bizarre double-pin scenario. As Styles hit Ellsworth with a superplex, both of their shoulders remained down for the three-count. The referee declared the match a draw, leaving Styles frustrated and Ellsworth still clinging to his Cinderella run. Though the match’s outcome was controversial, it showcased how even comedic characters like Ellsworth could find themselves in moments that fans would talk about for weeks.

4. John Cena vs. CM Punk — Raw (2013)

A high-stakes match between John Cena and CM Punk on Monday Night Raw in 2013 ended with one of the most discussed double pinfalls in modern WWE history. With a shot at The Rock’s WWE Championship on the line at WrestleMania 29, both men gave everything they had. Late in the match, as Cena attempted a hurricanrana, Punk countered into a powerbomb-style move, but both superstars’ shoulders were down when the referee made the three-count. Although the match was ultimately restarted after review, the double pinfall moment added extra drama to an already electric contest. Cena would eventually win, but this match proved why both men were at the top of WWE at that time — neither was willing to give an inch.

These legendary WWE double-pinfall matches remind fans why unpredictable endings remain some of the most exciting moments in wrestling history. Whether it’s a championship hanging in the balance or careers defined by a single moment, these matches are etched in the memories of fans for their intensity and controversy.